Get Widget

Who should Buffy choose?

5738 Votes
  • Start Date:
    1-21-2008
  • Last Vote:
    7-23-2008

Issue:

    Alright I made a campaign a few weeks ago hoping to get people behind a Buffy movie.  I have been very pleased with the amount of new members and their comments.  In thinking about a possible new movie one question keeps coming up.  Should Buffy ultimately end up with Angel or Spike?

Belief:

            I believe that if they do make a Whedonverse movie to tie up the loose ends of the plots of Angel and Buffy the Vampire Slayer, that Buffy should choose once and for all which vampire she loves the most.

            For anyone who isn’t familiar with this love triangle here is the most objective synopsis I can give.  Angel was Buffy’s first love.  He was her guide and protector in Sunny Dale until they had sex and he lost his soul turning into the evil Angelus.  Then he tormented her for a season until he got his soul back just before she had to send him too hell.  He of course got out of hell but had to bail because he got his own series set in Las Angeles.  In one of the early episodes of Angel he gets some demon blood in a cut on his hand and is turned human.  Buffy happens to be in Las Angeles at the time and it looks like they can now be together because his curse is truly lifted.  Unfortunately he is a champion that knows his job is not yet complete so he goes to an oracle that reverses time and Buffy has no knowledge of the one amazing day they had together.   In one of the final episodes of Buffy she does insinuate that they could be together someday.

            Spike arrived on the scene in the season two premiere of Buffy the Vampire Slayer.  He looks and talks like Billy Idol and has very heavy influence from Luke Perry’s character, Pike, in the original Buffy the Vampire Slayer movie starring Kristi Swanson.  His character was actually on the show much longer than Angel’s though evil for much longer.  In season 4 the military puts a chip in his head that shocks him if he tries to hurt humans.  He then discovers he can hurt Demons and becomes a pseudo good guy at the same time falling in love with Buffy even though he kind hates her too.  At the end of season six he goes to some sort of demon shaman and goes through trials and torture to get his soul back.  He and Buffy also had tons of sex because Spike was all about her and she was kind of tweaked out on account of the fact that she died went to heaven and was ripped back to earth by a magic spell.  But that is another story.

            So Whedon tried to tie this up by having Spike and Angel go to Italy only to find that Buffy was dating some immortal guy called “the immortal.”  I personally thought this was lame because you don’t see Buffy.  I think Sara Michelle Gellar had other obligations at the time.

            So I think the fans should decide.  If you think Buffy should be with her first love and you still remember that song that they used to play when they were together then vote for the Vampire with a soul who helps the helpless Angel.  If you feel that Buffy and Spike’s relationship was better developed in the plot and that he was more true to her because he sought out his soul and ended up later sacrificing himself to save the world then vote for the witty British rock star Vamp William the Bloody, aka Spike.

45%
I think that Buffy should be with Angel.
55%
I think Buffy should be with Spike.
Tell a FriendCreate a CampaignBookmark
Cast Your Vote
Forum Discussion for Who should Buffy choose?
123456789…next ›last »
Submitted by Lori L. on Wed, 07/23/2008 - 01:24

ok first of all... F*** soldier boy Riley! out of angel or spike? i DEFINITLY choose spike. obviously there was so much chemistry. sure she hated him but you see her affection towards him in season 7 even after angel shows up.. nevermind that kiss. SPUFFY FOREVER!!!

Submitted by Lori L. on Wed, 07/23/2008 - 01:29

oh and also.. angel is NOTHING compared to spike. buffy's whole hangup with spike was because he had no soul. well, he eventually gets one. angel was cursed with a soul and could lose it at any chance of happiness.. aka buffy. spike fought and earned for his soul.. for buffy. now who comes out the winner? spike does.. in my book anyways.

Submitted by DEBBIE R. on Tue, 07/22/2008 - 17:21

I loved Spike, but Buffy needs to be with Angel. He was her true love!

Submitted by Lindsay D. on Sun, 07/20/2008 - 06:48

angel is nicer and better than spike

Submitted by dot c. on Sun, 07/20/2008 - 01:16

I've never read the comics but I think Buffy should be with the BIG BAD; "SPIKE" . No one will ever ,ever love Buffy the way Spike does. Yes Angel was her first love and yes Angel did love Buffy BUT Angel never got deep into her soul like Spike did. Spike knew Buffy in a way that Angel could never reach and because of that Buffy could never be completly satisfied with Angel.

Submitted by sheila O. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 22:07

I love both the guys.Angel because he has been her first love.I think she should be with angel.The chemistry is still there from the last episode.I also love spike toward the end of season 7.He loves her also.It's hard to choose.Can't she choose both:)

Submitted by eb o. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 15:48

Angel 4 SURE!!!!! I stopped watching after season 3 when Angel left. And I didn't watch either show after that. I told myself if in the end she ends up with Angel I'll buy and watch all Angel and Buffy DVD'S until then I'm steering clear of the two. Although I sometimes read up on the commics to see if they have ended up already. That break-up was a b*tch to go through!!!

Submitted by becs w. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 13:54

she should defo be with spke , i mean have u seen him he is far better lookin then angel , and that body of his is so hot mmmmm

Submitted by Katie S. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 01:57

Angel was her first love and first love come and most of the time go. So defently Spike, not to mention Spike loved Buffy when he was evil so that leads me to believe that the man and the demon loved Buffy were as Angels demon did not. Also not to mention evil Spike got his soul for Buffy where as Angelus would have never done that and would of probably done things beyond attempting to rape her.

Pluse on top of every thing else Spike loved buffy more and would have done anything for her, I truly thank she relized how much in the end and finally let her guard down and let him in.

Submitted by Katie S. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 04:15

Oh yah and for those of you that said Riely WTF is your malfunction! Did we not watch the same show. He left her and he did it when she needed him the most! With his wo is me crap! Her Mom had a brain tumor for god sake what and she's supposed to be all, "oh Rielly I love you," and put all time and effort into him. No I don't think so. He was not a good man and he was more selfish than anyone on that show and he could never hanndle that buffy was stronger than him.

Submitted by Ashleigh W. on Tue, 07/15/2008 - 07:56

Spike. He may have done some bad things but ultimately he would do anything for Buffy.
Angel has moved on...they were good once but it could never last, he wouldn't even stay human for her, because he had to be macho and have strength to 'protect' her, which he didn't end up doing. He's just not as devoted to her...

Submitted by Preston K. on Sat, 07/12/2008 - 17:45

It has to be Angel..there's not even a doubt about this. It's the classic Ross and Rachael scenario all over again, it's what has to be for everything to feel right. I mean I'm a huge Spike fan and all I think the guy is way more bad ass than Angel, but if they ever do a movie and F this one up it will feel like crap just when Dawson's Creek ended the show with Joey choosing Pace instead of Dawson (sorry for throwing in a Dawson's Creek reference in there but if your a Buffy fan then you know the WB era i'm talking about).

Submitted by Debra G. on Mon, 07/14/2008 - 16:42

Angel moved on to Cordelia did you see the Angel series?Also Spike and Buffy are ment to be get real Spike has been there since season 2,Also Buffy and Spike went from Enemys to lovers to friends to soul mates,where was Angel all this time?I will tell you in LA thats where he was with Darla,Cordelia,Nina,ect and also Angel had a baby with Darla(Connor)so i really dont think Angel ever gave Buffy a single thought when he was with Darla,My point is Angel is a Father now and has sooo moved on he is over Buffy,Spike on the other hand has been there through the end,Spike has helped protect Buffy and her friend,family and the world,and Spike changed his whole existance and life to be with Buffy,Spike loves Buffy more than anything even his own life, Now tell me why Buffy should give up some one whos been there for her even when every one gave up on her and she was at the point of giving up again Spike shows up and gives her the will,strenght to go on,Why should Buffy choose her High School Boy Crush when shes a Woman now and the only one there to help her was Spike(between Spike or Angel)? Also if you rewatch the episodes again you would see Spike and Buffy are the real true Soulmates not Angel hes Cordelias soulmate not Buffys,i hope they bring Cordelia back for Angel so he has some one but Buffy shouldnt have to go back to the past cause honestly Buffy has surpast her High School teen innocent self and turned into a Hell of a Woman Spikes woman,so Buffy and Spike Forever.

Submitted by Katie S. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 01:59

I completely agree!!!!!

Submitted by Michelle F. on Sat, 07/12/2008 - 00:54

I think Buffy should be with Spike. Come on who died for her. He really loves Buffy. Spike all the way! Like I said Angel is boring.

Submitted by Laura N. on Fri, 07/11/2008 - 10:36

TRUE LOVE IS THAT WHICH GIVES THE MOST,WITHOUT ASKING ANYTHING IN RETURN.
< SPIKE ALL THE WAY>

Submitted by Marina D. on Thu, 07/10/2008 - 05:43

4 all Angel's fans. If you see Angel series you'll notice that Angel wasn't so in love with Buffy. He loved her,but he wasn't in love with her. After Will told him Buffy is dead,true,he left LA, but when he came back he was not so downcast. Cordi asked him if he is OK and he answered Yes and that was the problem ,that he is OK after her death. So, he moved on with his life. He didn't go to help Buffy's family or her friends. YESSS he really loved her....

Submitted by Katie S. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 02:03

Not to mention Spike counted the days, hours, minutes, and seconds Buffy was gone and hello people he was evil then and he still cared more than Angel!

Submitted by Tara V. on Thu, 07/10/2008 - 02:53

Well im gonna say angel, only because cordy died, and cordy and angel were so perfect for each other. and cause i think angel's better then spike, sorry spike fans, angel deserves to be human , after all that was the prophecy!

Submitted by Katie S. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 02:40

Yes but he signed his chance away, and on top of that I think an evil Vamp fighting for his soul and dieing to save the world is way up there on the I deserve to be human list. Also how do you thank Buffy would of felt if she new Angel chose to be a Vamp rather than being with her and then made her forget that experience. I personaly thank she would have been pist to no end. And as for the prohecy itself it never mentioned a name only that a souled vampire would be human one day. There are two souled vamps now not one. But I do agree that Angel and Cordy were perfect together.

Submitted by sheila O. on Thu, 07/17/2008 - 22:22

I don't think cordy and angel go togeather.I couldn't feel the chemistery in their characters at all, only as a best freind caring for another best freind.If cordy had any chemistery I think they should of keep Doyle in the first episode.He really liked cordy,and it seemed she cared for him in the end..

Submitted by AMBER M. on Wed, 07/09/2008 - 20:01

i'm sorry i'm a sucker for Angel

Submitted by charity s. on Wed, 07/09/2008 - 19:02

I THINK BUFFY SHOULD BE WITH SPIKE. I WISH THAT THEY WOULD BRING CORDY BACK TO BE WITH ANGEL.

Submitted by kirsten k. on Wed, 07/09/2008 - 08:34

as much as i love spike buffy nd angel r pretty much destiny

Submitted by adela P. on Tue, 07/08/2008 - 07:07

All this comments are about the type of person we are(or we like). Some of us like a peaceful relationship, no intense emotions, go to work,come back home,make dinner and go to sleep,than they voted 4 Angel.
Others like an intens, exciting, hot, funny and passionate relationship,so we voted 4 Spike.

Submitted by Casey B. on Tue, 07/08/2008 - 05:26

well it cant be angel he signd away the sansue when sitting with the members of the black thorn, there is no real boy for angel, not anymore.

Submitted by Liz F. at Facebook on Tue, 07/08/2008 - 01:41

This all depends on who ultimately will "become a real boy" after the final battle. I do believe this honor should go to Angel, thus solving the "Who should Buffy choose?" problem. Although I love Spike and Buffy together, Angel has fought longer and harder on the side of good and deserves a little touchin' and squeezin' with the Buff.

Submitted by Angela M. on Mon, 07/07/2008 - 18:25

buffy should be with angel. they look good together and they were so in love before.

Submitted by Cora S. on Mon, 07/07/2008 - 10:36

That's hard because Angel's kinda like the romantic relationship and Spike's the more lusty one. I'd have to go with Spike just because he is still so in love with Buffy and is so wiling to change for her. Angel has kinda moved on with his life with Cordy. Plus, I mean come on Spike's amazing!

Submitted by Felicia P. on Tue, 07/08/2008 - 20:16

I agree. And sometimes love's a loaded gun!

123456789…next ›last »
Loading People...